Electroresponsive device and system



Sept. 22, 1931. J. W. McNAIRV ELECTRORESPONSIVE DEVICE- AND SYSTEM Filed June 22, 1928 2 Sheets-Sheet l V Inventor-z JacobW McNairy by xflv' His Attohney Sept. 22, 1931. J w McNAIRY 1,824,728

ELECTRORESPONSIVEJ DEVICE AND SYSTEM Filed June 22, 1928 2 Sheets-Sheet 2 Fig. 3.

JAAAAA vv vv MUM vv vv AAAAAA vv vv lnvertoh: Jacob W. MCNaiYX Patented Sept. 22, 1931 STATES PATENT OFFICE JACOB W. MCNAIRY, OF ERIE, PENNSYLVANIA, ASSIGNOR TO GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY, A CORPORATION OF NEW YORK ELECTRORESPONSIVE DEVICE AND SYSTEM Application filed June 22, 1928. Serial No. 287,540.

This invention relates to electroresponsive or cars from an overhead trolley system with devices and systems for the selective control a common grounded rail return circuit, there of network distribution systems, particularly ordinarily are four trolleys to be fed from alternating current network systems in which each transformer substation along the line.

a plurality of feeder circuits are connected In order to localize trouble due to groundin parallel relation between supply sources ing of the trolleys, it is desirable that each of or substations so that power may be fed to the four trolleys be sectionalized at each subeach feeder directly from the source at either station. Th at is, provision should be made end or through the other feeders in case of for separately disconnecting the trolley feed- 30 failure of any source, ers running each way from a common supply \Vith a network distribution system of this bus at each substation in case a fault develops character it is highly desirable that in case n any p rtion or all of the trolleys in any any particular feeder becomes short-circuited section without disturbing power flow to adso as to produce a sudden abnormally large Jacent interconnected sections of the trolley.

15 and dangerous flow of current thereto, the My present invention is particularly apfaulty feeder should be isolated from the p icable to provide selective protection for system as rapidly as possible without interthe trolleys in such a system. rupting the current supply to the other feed- Briefly, the protective system of the presers. Likewise, where there is a sudden exent invention provides the following proteco cessive flow of current to more than one of tion in such a system. When a sudden fault the feeders or all of the feeders due to short develops in any section of trolley due to circuit or other fault, all of the faulty feedgrounding or short circuiting, each end of the ers should be disconnected from the power faulty trolley section is disconnected at each supply system. In addition, provision of the adjacent substations. In case more 4 should be made to take care of gradually inthan one trolley or all the trolleys develop creasing overloads in the feeders, as well as Such a fault in any section, all of the faulty short circuits and other faults at the seVeral trolley sections are quickly disconnected at sources or substations to insure continuity the adjacent substations without disturbing f i i th System the power flow in the other feeders or in adse One of the principal objects of the present jacent trolley sections. Moreover, in C s invention is to provide an improved arrangeof internal faults at any substation the feedment and connection of electroresponsive proers are maintained connected to the adjacent tective apparatus whereby such selective cousubstations and are disconnected from the trol of the feeder system and supply sources faulty substation only in the event the fault 25 therefor may be obtained. can not be cleared by opening other circuits 35 Although not necessarily limited thereto, at the substat1ons. the present invention is particularly ad- In carrying the present invention into efvantageous in connection with the protection feet in a single phase alternating current trolof alternating current feeder systems for ley feeder protective system of the above char 4 multi-track electrified railways. In such sysacter advantage may be taken of the action terns power ordinarily is supplied by high of the unidirectional transformer tripping voltage transmission lines and transformer circuit arrangement described and claimed substations are located at suitable intervals in my copending application Serial No. along the railroad for transforming the high 89,247, filed February 18, 1926. Briefly, this voltage power to a lower voltage suitable for transformer tripping circuit arrangement the overhead trolleys or third rail power provides a unidirectional tripping impulse supply conductors for the electric locomotives upon a rapid increase of current in an alterand cars of the railroad. Where a four track nating current circuit. In accordance with railroad system is involved and single phase the present invention the ends of the four 50 power is supplied to the electric locomotives parallel trolley feeder circuits sectionalized 1m at each substation may be protected by circuit breakers each provided with such a unidirectional transformer trip circuit with the transformer trip circuits differentially interconnected so as to provide the selective protection outlined above. The differential arrangement is such that the unidirectional current supplied by the transformer trip circuit of a faulty trolley feeder serves not only to trip out quickly the disconnecting circuit breaker therefor, but also assists in preventing the tripping of the unimpaired trolley feeders in the section. Moreover, when more than one, or all, of the trolley feeders in a section simultaneously develop short circuits at exactly the same instant the differentially interconnected transformer trip circuits function to disconnect the trolley feeders but at a higher value of current in each feeder than when the short circuit occurs in only one feeder. hat is, where a certain percentage increase in current will effect the tripping of the disconnecting circuit breaker for one feedor, when faults develop on two or more feeders at exactly the same time, the percentage of current increase required to effect tripping of each breaker is automatically and progressively increased as the number of feeders developing faults at exactly the same instant increases. Moreover, by means of the present invention the percentage increase of current required for tripping the breakers individually as well as simultaneously may be adjusted at will. This automatic increase of tripping current for a plurality of feeder circuit breakers may be utilized to insure that in case of an internal short circuit at any substation the feeder circuits are not disconnected from the adjacent substations and furthermore are not disconnected from the faulty substation except in the case of a bus short circuit. In case of a bus short circuit, the differential unidirectional transformer trip circuits are designed to be ineffective and the feeder disconnecting switches may be operated under these conditions by suitable auxiliary relays such as standard incoming and outgoing bus current differential protective relays. This selective operation of the unidirectional tripping transformer circuit to differentiate between internal faults at the substation and faults on the feeder line is of the greatest advantage in maintaining continuity of service, as otherwise the power supplied to all feeders connected to a faulty substation would be interrupted with the usual forms of feeder protective systems.

In the drawings Fig. 1 is a diagram showing schematically a typical four track sectionalized railway feeder system of the above character involving a plurality of transformer substations; Fig. 2 is a diagram shoving the detailed connection of the transformer trip circuits for the disconnecting switches at the ends of the four trolley feeders of each section at each substation; and Fig. 3 is a diagram showing a modified connection arrangement employing rectifiers for tripping the disconnecting switches.

In the schematic diagram of Fig. 1 power is supplied from the high voltage transmission line IJ to the several snbetations S S 3, which it will be unde;

,od are located at s itable intervals along the four track clectrilied railroad and arra l to feed the .CilUDS A, B, C, D, of the trolley or third re s tem coo stituting the power supply conductors for the locomotive equipment. it wi l be understood that in accordance with the usual practice the feeders in each section A, B, U, D, are cor.- nected at frequent intervals to the individual trolleys or third rails associated with each of the four tracks involved, and the grounded rails of the track are utilized for the return circuit. In the power supply system indicated, the high voltage supply lines L are shown as single phase lin At the respective substations S1, S2, S3, suitable transformers T1 to T6 are provided for reducing the voltage of the current supplied from the line L to a value suitable for application to the trolley or third rail feeders from which the locomotive equipment is energized. As indicated schematically in the drawings one tern'iinal of the low voltage side of each transformer is grounded to show that it is connected to the common rail circuit and the other low voltage terminal of the several transformers are connected to the correspond ing substation busses H H respectively. In order to localize trouble due to grounding or other faults on the feeder sections A, B, (I, D, or in the several substations, the feeders are sectionalized at each substation and provision is made for individually disconnecting each end of the four feeders in each of the sections A, B, C, D, from the respective supply busses H1 to H6 by means of the corre? sponding groups of disconnecting switches D1 to D6. In addition, the pairs of busses H1 and 2, H3 and 4, H5 and 6, at the respective substations are arranged to be either connected together or separated by the respective disconnecting switches D7, 8 and 9. Likewise, the low voltage side of the transformers from which the respective busses are fed are disconnected therefrom by the disconnecting switches D10 to D15, which may be arranged to be operated under the control of suitable relays providing overload, under-voltage reverse power and other desired protection in accordance with standard practice. Fur-then more, any suitable form of disconnecting switch for the high voltage side of the transformers may also be provided as indicated in the drawings. As the present invention is concerned primarily with the arrangement and connection of the groups of feeder disconnecting switches D1 to D6, no further detailed description of the transformer and bus mil) link

disconnecting switches is deemed necessary. In accordance with the presentinvention the disconnecting switches inleach of the groups D1 toD6 are arranged to operate 5 individually to disconnect the corresponding 'fee'der in case of an excessive increase of ourrenttherein such 5 as would- 'occur upon grounding of the feeder. Moreo ver', where faults on more than 'onefeeder in any section occur .at' the same instant thecorre'sponding disconnecting switches are arranged to operate upon a sudden increase in current but as previously pointed out the present invention insures that a greater percentage increase in current inxeach feeder is required'in case a plurality of feeders are short-circuited at the same'instant. 1

F ig; 2 diagrammatically shows the construction and connection arrangement of the groups of disconnecting switches D1 to D6 in accordance with a preferred form of the present invention. Thus at substation S2 the feeder bus H3 is supplied with power through transformer T3 from the high voltage transmission line L,-as previously indicated. The trolleyfeeders B1, B2,=B3, B4, at one end of the'sectionB are supplied with power from the bus H3, through the circuit breakers CB, CBO, CB5, CB0, which constitute the group of disronnectin switches D3.

As shown diagrammatically in Fig. 2 of the drawing, each of these circuit breakers is of the high speed type described and claimed in the Tritle Reissue Patent No. 15,441, dated August 29, 1922, and also embodies the trip free feature of the Tritle Patent N 0. 1,560,440 of November 3, 1925. Briefly, this form of circuit breaker comprises a movable circuit controlling switch element 10 which is normally held in circuit closing engagement with the cooperating switch element 11 by the electromagnet 12 having the armature 13 mechanically connected w'th the movable switch element 10. The electromagnet 12 is provided with a holding winding 14 and a tripping winding 15, the holding winding 14 being normally energize-'5 from a suitable direct current source and the tripping winding 15 being arranged to effect the release of the armature 13 when energized with a unidirectional current in the manner described morefully hereinafter. The arrangement is such that the tripping winding 15 shifts the holding flux of the electromagnet 12 from the armature 13 across the air gap between the poles of the electromagnet 12 when the tripping winding 15 is energized with current in the proper direction.

' A very rapid opening of the circuit breaker I is accomplished by the spring 16 which strongly biases the movable switch element 10 "to the'circuit opening position. A suitable closing mechanism 17 is provided and is shown as of the manual type for the sake of' clarity, although an electromagnctically operated mechanismrordinarily would be employed. The trip free characteristic of the eircuitbreaker is-ebtain'ed as diagrammaticallyillustratedin the drawings by pivoting 'themovableswitcli inember '10 upon the supporting a'rnr I18 which carries the armature 13'. In this way their operation of the'roller '19 of the closing mechanism against the lower'end-of the switch element 10 sets up .a strainimthe biasing'spring 16 and moves the armature13 int6=engageinent with the poles of theholding electromagnet 12 while still inaintai'ning'the switch element 10 out of engagementwviththe element 11. Upon release of the closing mechanism '17 the supporting 'arm' 18 is' maintained fixed by the holding 'electro'magnet 12and-the biasing spring 16 swings-the switch element 10 into engagement with the cooperating element 11 about its pivotal connection "with thc supporting arm 18. Eachjof the other circuit breakers CBO, CB6, C130, is of similar construction.

' The normally magnetized transformer tripping'circ'uit arrangement for supplying unidirectionalcurrent to the tripping winding15 of the circuit breaker in the proper d'irection to effect release thereof is of the type described and broadly claimed in my copending application Ser al No. 89,247. filed February 18, 1926. As diagrammaticall r illustrated in Fig. 2 this transformer tripping arrangement comprises the two transformers and 31 having their primary windings 32 and '33 connected to be ener zed in series from the current y in the feeder line B], w iich is controlled by circuit breaker CB. T he transformer 3-2 may be a standard type of current ti'illl-iformer, and the transformers -0 and 2-?! also are o's' a similar type. The resistor 35 is celinected across the terminals of the curr nt transformer 34 in order to properly load the secondary circuit of this transformer that the normal value of current in the secondary circuit thereof may he obtained. The secondary windings36 and 37 of the pair of transformers 30 and 31 are connected reverse ly in series as indicated in the drawing to supply the unidirectional tripping impulse to the winding 15 of the circuit breaker CH. The normal magnetization of the magnetic circuits of the transformers 30 and 31 is obtained by energizing the secondary windings 36 and 37 of the transformers from the direct current supply source indicated as and in the drawings. The circuit for this normal transformer magnetizing current may be traced from the negative supply line through the transformer secondary \Ylr'lillgs 36 and 37, the tripping winding 15 and thence through the holding winding 14 and the contact of relay 38 to the positive line. Thus, the current in this circuit serves to normally energize both the holding electromagnet 14 a and the magnetic-Li struturesr the trarisf'ormersBO and 31.; 5.

.:j The, normally magnetized tripping 1 trans.- formers and holding ielectiomagn'et' .for ,'the

' other circuit b1eakeI'S=I-'CBa;mb,-'QZfilQQCODr structed and arranged preciselyathe same way asdescribed in connection with the circuit breaker CB. -;-Ho we ver .it..-will- 'be observed that an equalizing connection for bus 40 is connected betweenwthejwtrippingl and holding winding ofeachfof the'four circuit breakers and that a balancing-resistor 41, preferably of the adjustable type,- as, indicated in the dra wings, is interconnected between the equalizing bus 40 and the negative: supply line. Thus the equalizing bus and-balancing :resistor provide a-common; return: path-for the unidirectional tripping impulses supplied by all of the tripping transformers. Also the equalizing bus 40 serves to connect the secondary windings of each pair of tripping transforiners, together with the trippingwinding of the associated circuit breaker in differential circuit relation with the transformer secondary winding and circuit breaker tripping winding of each'other circuitbreaker. 'In tracing these differential .-circuits..in Fig. 2, it will be noted thatcone differential circuit extends from the upper direct current supply line, indicated as through the econdary winding 37 of the transformer 31, the secondar winding 36 of the transformer 30, the tripping windingl5, and thence to the equalizing bus 40. Asecond differential uit extends from the upper direct current pply line through the secondary windings 1e transformers 31a and a, tripping ha to the equalizing bus 40. A ifi'erential circuit extends from the .tzpply line through the secondary of the transformersSlb and 30b,

the t ping winding 15b to the equalizing bus .20. A fourth differential circuit extends f" m the upper supply line through the sect r7 windings of the transformers 310 and f I the tripping winding 150 to the equaliz in," bus 40. Each of these differential circuits also in multiple relation with acircuit incurinz: the balancing resistor 41 which ex- -.s' from the upper supply linefto the "ting b11540. This differential. tripping .1 arrangement permits the selective operat on of the corresponding circuit breakers in case one or EHOIQOI' allcf the feeder lines ill to PA should separately or s multaneously become short circuited or develop other serious faults producing a rapid increase in current therein in the manner now to be described.

As set forth in my'previously mentioned application. Serial No. 8924?, the normal direct current. magnetization of the cooperating pairs of tripping transformers, together with the reverse connection either of the secondary windings as shown or of the primary windings ifgdesiied, insuresjthat Iaunidirectional-currentimpulse supplied to the tripping .windinggf the-high speed circuit breakcn'upqn theloccurrence-of a' rapid increase of curireht;:inithe 'nt m ryswi f ing. f th fir pping; rans ormers ans, i ca e a y onev 0f ,the ;feeder,, linjes B1 to .Blbecomesshort-circuit'ed witha-resultirlgrushpf current therein; the corre s pondingone of the current transformers /34, 34g;,=3';34b, 3&0, i1 nmediately: sup- .plies a-fcorrespondingincrease-in} current to the primary; w indir gs of the corresponding ipairi'ofntripp ng tr ns ers-1; I. i 1 Briefly the'prgduction of the unidirectional c rre ri pul vi i h i c t rywindi of the tripping transformers under these conditions is due to the fact that theincreased p ary c rren Qfithe pa n-Qft pp ng t i orm r i en s to increas the m gn t m of; n f. he itnans rme se ddecrease that of; the gtherptransformerm Thus, j with the normaldirect ,current'magnetization of both transformers at yalueneargthe bend in the saturation curve, afgreater. change in magnetization results in ;the tparticular transformer in whichthe primary winding tends to decrease the magnetization, than in the other tr nsference n? p This greaterchange of flux in the transformer having its magnetization decreased inherently induces a voltage in itssecondary winding greater than that induced in the secondary winding of the other transformer. Consequentl the predominating secondary voltage is e ective to supply a tripping impulse to the tripping winding of the corresponding circuit breaker. It should be noted that in case the short circuit and corresponding current rush in the feeder line occurs during either halfcycle, a corresponding one of the pair of tripping transformers has predominating voltage inducedin the secondary winding thereof in the manner just described. Thus, the impulse supplied to the. tripping windingof the circuit breaker always in the same direction irrespective of the direction of the alternating current at the instant the short circuit on the feeder line occurs. I

Feehlefshort circuits 7 VJith the differential"connection'between the transformer; tripping circuits for the four feeder circuit breakers as illustrated in Is 2, the tripping impulse produced upon therush of current in a short-circuited feedor by the pair of tripping transformers associated therewith flows in the direction to effect tripping of the corresponding circuit breaker but returns in the reverse direction through the tripping windings of the other circuit breakers and the balancing resistor in multiple; For example, when the feeder line B1 becomes short circuited, the pair of tripping transformers 30 and 31 function to supply the tripping impulse to the winding in the proper direction to effect release of the armature 18 and thereby permit the movable contact 10 to quickly move to the circuit interrupting position thereb immediately disconncctin feeder B1 from the power supply bus at snbs'lation S2. After passing through the tr' )ping winding 15 the circuit for the trippi impulse extends through each of the tri ping windings 15a, 1), c, and the s condary wine gs of the corresponding transformers and also through the balancing resistor 41 with all of these in multiple circuit relation. The loading resistors connected. across the primary windings of the other tripping transformers serve effectively to lower the in'ipedancc of these transformers to the return tripping current. As pre viously pointed out, the return tripping current passing through the tripping windings 1531!, 6, c, is in the reverse direction from that IOtlllll'fltl to effect release of the corresponding circuit breakers. In a similar manner he disconnecting circuit breaker in group H2 for fee-'ler B1 operates to disconnect the short-circuited eeder B1 from the power supply bus at substation S1. It should be noted that with the high speed circuit breakers as illustrated the complete disconnection of the feeder occurs almost instantaneously upon the short-circuiting thereof, the action ordinarily reqizging only one-half cycle in circuits of commercial frequency.

In case the short circuit occurs on any of I the other feeder lines B3, B l. the tripping transform associated therewith function in the same I. inner to supply a tripping impulse in the proper direction to the tripping wind ng of the corresponding feeder disconnocting circuit breaker at each of the substat ons S2. but in the reverse direction through the tripping windings of the rema ning circuit breakers. Thus this differential connection of the transformer trip c rcuits insures that only the tripping winding of the circuit breaker for the faulty feedrr is operatively energized, while at the same t me toe tripping w ndings of the circuit breakers for the other parallel feeders are energized in the direction tending to maintain thcs e feeder breakers closed.

lo case a olnrality of feeders develop short rru t faults at the same ins ant, tripping mpulses are pplietl to e fect instant release of th corre non-ding f eder circuit breakers hr the tripping transformers associated therewith. However. in this case. the number of para el re urn paths for the tripping iinoulses necessarily is decreased directly a the number of feeder lines simultaneously deve oping faults increases. Thus with r'h-urt c rcuit at the same instant on the feed cr lines P92. the onli return path for {no tripping ini 'iulse is through the single remaining tripping circuit of the circuit breaker for the feeder B4 in parallel with the balancing resistor 41 since each of the pair of tripping transformers for the feeder lines B1, B2, B3 have equal active voltages induced in the secondary circuit thereof tending to send tripping current through the tripping windings of the corresponding circuit breakers to the equalizing bus 40. With the number of multiple return paths thus reduced, the value of the voltage induced in each transformer trip circuit necessary to supply the impulse required for effecting release of the corresponding circuit breaker is increased. Consequently, a greater current icrease in each of the faulty feeders is required to effect simultaneous disconnection thereof from the bus H3 than is required to effect disconnection of a single faulty feeder.

When all of the feeders in any section develop short circuits at exactly the same instant, the only return path for the combined tripping impulses at each of the adjacent substations at the ends of the feeder sections is through the balancing resistor. In this case the maximum increase of current per feeder is required to produce suflicient current in the tripping windings to effect operation of all of the circuit breakers. By varying the value of the balancing resistor, the increase of current per feeder for simultaneous faults of a plurality of feeders may be adjusted at will with respect to the increase in current required to disconnect each feeder separately, As previously pointed out, this characteristic permits the tripping current required for operation of all the circuit breakers in case of internal substation short circuits to be made greater than the exchange current between substations while still canable of readily responding to separate or simultaneous short circuits of the feeders and in this way maintain continuity of service under all possible conditions. It will be understood that the bus and transformer disconnecting switches shown in Fig. 1 may be arranged in accordance with standard practice to be operated under the control of suit able overload relays, differential incoming and outgoing bus current relays or the like (not shown) to provide adequate protection for the substati n apparatus and circuits upon the occurrence of internal faults at the substation such as bus short circuits, transformer short c rcuits or short circuits on the high voltage lines adjacent the substation. In this connection it should be noted that while not shown in the drawings it is desirable for insuring continuity of service that a plurality of high voltage lines he provided for independently supplying powcr to the transformers at each substation in case any one of the lines should fail. Thus two lines may be employed in the system shown in Fig. 1 with each of the two transformers at each substation connected to a different one of the lines.

If desired, the feeders H3 to B4 may be arranged to be disconnected from the substation bus B1 in case of a short circuit on the bus or other internal fault at the substation by means of the protective relays 38, 38a, 38b, 380. These devices may be of the form indicated having a potential winding 50 and a current winding 51 with an induction disk armature arranged to actuate the relay contact in case of either failure of voltage on the substation bus B1 or excessive current flow through the feeder circuits connected thereto or a combination of these faults. To obtain this result the windings 50, 50a, 50b, 500 of the corresponding relays are connected to be energized from the potential transformer 52 and the current windings 51, 51a. 51?), 510 are separately energized from the current transformers 52, 52a, 52?), 520, respectively.

Since the circuit of the holding windings 14, 14a, 14?), 140 of the feeder disconnecting circuit breakers are energized through the contacts of the respective relays 38a. 88?). 380, the opening of the contact of any one of the e relays serves to dcenergiae the holding magnet of the corresponding circuit breaker and thereby permit operation thereof to the circuit opening position. Thus, the relays 38, 38a, 38b. 38/ provide for disconnecting the corresponding feeders B1 to B4 in case of short circuit of the substation bus H3 and also in case any one of the feeders carries a gradually increasing overload current, the increase being insufficient to produ e operation of the transformer circuit breaker tripping circuits. In this way the transformer tripping circuits function to provide instantaneous release of the feeder disconnecting circuit breakers in case of short circuits on the feeder lines while the relays of the type shown produce operation of the feeder cisconnecting circuit breakers in case of steadily increasing overloads. Likewise, other suitable relays, such as differential or reverse power relays. may be arranged to open the holding coil circuit in case of faults developing at the substation busses or in any of the transformer or high voltage line circuits. With this arrangement of protective apparatus at each substation let us assume that a short circuit occurs on the bus H2 at substation S1 in the system shown in Fig. 1. The protective relays associated with the disconnecting switches D7, D11, and possibly the disconnecting switches on the high voltage side of the. transformer T2 at once start operation to disconnect the short-circuitcd bus H2 from the power supply. However. with proper adjustment of the balancing resistors associated with the transformer trip circuits for the groups of disconnecting switches D2 at substation S1 and D3 at substation S2,

operation of these breakers at high speed the exchange current from substation S2 to substation S1 due to bus short circuit may be prevented so as to maintain the feedcrs in section B energized from the power source. The protective relays controlling the circuit of the holding windings for the feeder disconnecting circuit breakers in group D2 at substation S1 immediately function to produce operation of these circuit breakers to disconnect the short-circuited bus H2 from the feeders. The feeders, however, are maintained energized from the substation S2.

Let us now assume that by some extraordinary coincidence all the feeders B1 to B4 are grounded at precisely the same instant. The possibility of such an event of course is extremely remote as even in the case of a wreck or other accident bringing down all the overhead trolleys in section B, one or two of the trolle s almost inevitably will be short-circuited and the short circuit cleared in onehalf cycle by operation of the high speed disconnecting circuit breakers at each end of the feeder before the actual short circuit of the remaining trolleys occurs within such a limited space of time. In the event, however. that all feeders are short-circuited at precisely the same time, for example, midway between the substations S1, S2, the resulting rush of current from the bus at each substation is greater than the exchange current between substations in case of a bus short circuit at either substation. This is due to the fact that the impedance of the circuit with a short circuit midway b tween the substations is materially less than in the case of a bus short circuit. Consequently. the groups of disconnecting switches D2 and D3 at the rc spective substations will operate at high speed to immediately disconnect all of the feeders in section B from the source of power.

Likewise, if the short circuit at the same instant on all the feeders occurs directly adiacent one of the substations. say substation S1. the group of disconnecting switches D2 immediately responds to disconnect all feeders from substation S1. In this case the situat on. as far as the group of circuit breakers D3 is concerned when the simultaneous short circuit occurs. i substantially the same as in the case of a bus short circuit due to the increased impedanc in the feeder circuits with the short circuit adjacent substation S1. Cons onently. these b eakers initially remain inactive until after the feeders are disconnected from the bus at sub tation 31. When this occurs the excessive short circuit current in the high voltage lines is reduced and conseouently the voltage suddenly increases and thereby produces an increased How of current to the short-circuited feeder lines from the substation S2. This additional increase of current is sufficient to effect operation of i rev ves the group of feeder'disconnecting switchesfD3 thereby isolatinghll'pt the faulty feeders from the'pow'ersiipplysource; f I The'prcfe'rredform ofthe invention shown in Fig. Q-perm'its the'full advantage of the high speed circuit breaker; as' well asthe in ductive unidirectional transformer trip cir-j cuit arrangement therefor covered by my H previously mentioned application Serial 1N0. 89.247 to be utilized in'anetworkisyst'emto provide high speed selective parallel feeder protection in the manner previously-described. However, in case It is notdeslred to utilize the increase of current "principlez'of plying unidirectional tripping current tothe high speed circuit breakers in the-manner illustrateddiagrammatically in Fig. 3.

'In general this rectifier trip circuit er rangement is'substantially the same as shown in Fig. 2 except that the tripping windings 15, 1 15a, 15?), 150, of the corresponding breakers are arranged to be supplied with current in the proper direction to eifect release ofithe circuit breakers through the agency of thecurrent transformerstlO, 60a, 60b, 60c, and the cooperatin pairs of alternatin current to unidirectional current rectifying devices 61, (31a. 61?), 610. which 'may be of any desired type. Also in this case the holding'windinns 14, 1.4a, 146.140, of the high speed circuit breakers may be energized directly fromthe direct current supply source indicated as andwith the l'ioldin z circuits arranged to be interrupted by the contacts 38, 38a, 38b, 380. of suitable reverse power. differential, or other forms of protective relays to take care of internal substation faults, IS'ClQSCIlbQd in connection with the system of Fig.2. The current transformers 60. 60a. 60b, 600, are of the usual type employed with rectifiers havinn mid tap with the end terminals each connected to one of the pair of cooperating rectifying: devices.

i n accordance with the present invention. each tripping transformer and cooperating pair of rectifiers are connected to supply the rectified current. to the tripping winding of the corresponding circuit breaker in the prop or direction to ell ect release thereof the transformer and rectifier units and the tripping windinys are interconnected in such manner with the resistors R1. R2. R4 and the balancing: resistor R5 that the value of abnormal current in any of the feedr lines l l3: B B required to eii'ect simultaneous re ease of more than one circuit breaker increases proportionately with the number of feeder lines involved. That is. where a certaiuvalue of current each feeder line is required to effect separate release of the corresponding circuit breaker, when two,-or

murder all of the feeder lines'ure at the same instant subjected to an excessive current, the value ofciirrent per feeder required to trip each breakerismateri'ally increased.

*In orderfteohtainthi's result,'one side of e ther the trippingwindings'15, a, 15!}, I 56, ma'yfbe connectedto an equalizing bus 62 wliile'=tl1 emid-poinfof each of the transform GOiffiOugGOb; 60c, likewise may be conn'cted to an equalizing bus '63. ZThje other terminals of the tripping windings which are s iplalietl from the commonfpoint of each pair of'fre'ctifiersare'connected to the equalizing bus ti3tlirough the cori'espending bypass resisters R1; R2; R3; R4; 'In'i'addition. the balancing resistor R5 is interconnected between thefeqiializi'ng busses 62*and 63, Wmth tliis modificcl arangement let us assume that the feeder line'Bl is short-ci'rcuited. Under these conditions the current transforme'r SO: supplies current through one of the pair'of rectifiers 61 associated therewith du rin ifeaeh half cycle inthe proper direc ion to produce tripping of the circuit breaker CB, the return circuit for the rectified tripping current extending: lro 'n the equalizing bus 62 through each ofthe tripping windings of theotlier circui t breakers and the correspond ing jre sis'tors R2, R3. R i'and the balancing rcsistor H5 all in multiple circuit relation to the equalizin g bus 63 and thence to the mid tap of the-current transformer 60. Thus, the return tripping current passes through the tripping windings of the other circuit lJYQfiliQl's in thereverse direction and tends to prevent operation of these breakers. in case of separate short'circuit on anv of the o her feeder lines the current transformer and rcc ificrs associated therewith supply current in th properdirection in the tripping wind ngs ot the corresponding circuit breaker and with the return circuit through all the other trippine windings and resistors in multiple in precisely the same manner.

Thus where more than one feeder develops a short circuit at the same instant. the number of multiple return p ths for the tr pping current is correspondingly decreased and consequently and increased alue of tripping current is required to effect simultaneous release of a plurality of the circuit breakers. In the extraordinary case where all of the feeder lines are simultaneously short-circuited. the tripping current of all the circuit breakers passes through the balancing resistor R5. thereby requiring the maximum value of current per feeder to etl'ect simultaneous release thereof.

By proper adjustment of the resistors Rl to R4and the balancing resistor R5. it will be evident that the same dlSClllnlllRtll'ifI action in the case of substation l us circuits may be obtained with the rectified unidirectional trip circuit arrangement shown in Fig. 3 as described in connection with the transformer inductive tripcircuit; arrangementiof; Fig. 2.; That is, the current required-perfeeder for: simultaneous operation of 13.111 the, circuit breakers may bemade' greater than theeX- change current .betweenxsubstations, thus preventing operation ofthe'feede'r discon necting circuit breakers in-case-ofbus shorts or other internal faults by, the rectifier. trip circuits which, however,- are at all: times ca; pable of taking care of any-condition of short circuit on the feeders themselves, i

From the foregoing it will be apparent that the present invention enablesade uate selec; tive protection of ,the parallel fee encircaits and substation apparatus to be obtained under practically any. conditionnof fault that may occur in the system and at the same time maintain the feeders-energized from the high voltage power source'under all possible conditions. I

- ,What I claim as newand=desire to secure by Letters Patent of the. United States, is:

1. In combination, ;plurality.- of. parallel feeders interconnectingtwo supply. stations therefor, a plurality offeederdisconnecting switches, each having automatic operating means responsive to-short' circuit fault ,currents in a corresponding feeder .for discon necting the same from'a corresponding one of the supplv stations, and automaticelectrical means for preventing operation of the feeder disconnecting switches for each station when internal short circuit faults occur at the other station.

In combination, a plurality of parallel ccders, a separate circuit breaker for each ceder having automatic operating means norn'ially responsix e to predetermined abnorsent conditions therein, and automatic electrical means for insuring the non-response of said automatic operating means for the circuit breakers when said predetermined abnori al current conditions occur simultzine-rnis ly in the feeders.

combination, a plurality .of parallel cederc, a plurality of circuit breakers, each c acted to control a corresponding one of said feeders and each having a tripping winding, separate means for operatively energizing the tripping winding of the correspond in: circuit breaker in response to abnormal current conditions in the corresponding feeder, and means including electrical connections between said tripping windings and said energizing means for automatically rendering the circuit breakers less responsive to abnormal current conditions upon the simultaneous occurrence of said abnormal current conditions in a plurality of-feeders.

4. In combination, a plurality of alternating current feeders, a plurality of switches having unidirectional current responsive operating means therefor, each for controlling a corresponding feeder, a separate alternat' ing to unidirectional current transforming meansjassociated with each feeder for,snp plying; unidirectional energizing current to the operating means of the corresponding switch to geifect i operation thereof upon the occurrence of abnormal current conditions in the'corresponding feeders, said transforme ing means being differentially interconnected to restrict the unidirectional currents jointly supplied thereby to, the-operating means of the;corresponding-switches upon the simultaneous occurrence? of, abnormal current conditions-in more than one of the-feeders. In combination, a plurality of alternat i'ng current feeders having a common supply source,- aplurality'of switches, each for disconnecting a corresponding feeder line from the common supply-source,"and separate unidirectional'inductive means for operating each of the switches -in resp'onseto a predetermined increase'of current in the corre-' sponding feeder, said inductive means being differentially interconnected to require a greater'simultaneous increase of current in a plurality of the feeders to effect operation of the corresponding switches.

6. In combination, a plurality of circuit breakers, each connected to control-a separate circuit, automatic 'means responsive to predetermined current conditions in each circuit for operating the corresponding circuit breaker,and aut'omaticelectrical means for preventing operation of the'circuit breakers by=saidfirst means when said predetermined current conditions occur simultaneously in the circuits.

7. In combination, a plurality of parallel feeders, a plurality of electrical devices, each having an operating winding, and a plurality of current supply devices therefor, each operable responsively to predetermined conditions in a corresponding feeder and connected in series'with the operating winding of a corresponding electrical device, with all the series circuits differentially connected in multiple whereby upon operation of different portions of the current supply devices correspondingly different values of current are supplied to the operating windings of the corresponding electrical devices.

8. In combination, a plurality of parallel feeders, aplurality of electrical devices, each having an operating winding, a plurality of current supply devices therefor each operable responsively to predetermined conditions in a corresponding feeder and connected in series relation with the operating winding of a corresponding electrical device, with all the series circuits differentially interconnected in multiple, and a current regulating device connected in multiple circuit relation with all of said series circuits for varying the value of current supply to the corresponding operating windings upon operation of different portions of the current supply devices. 9. In combination, a plurality of alternatingcurrent feeder lines, a plurality of independently operable switches, each connected to control a corresponding feeder line and each having an electroresponsive operating means requiring energization thereof in a predetermined direction to effect operation of the switch, and inductive means associated with each feeder line to be responsive to a rapid increase of current therein and interconnected with the electroresponsive operating means of said switches to supply energization in the said predetermined direction to the operating means of the switch in any feeder line having a rapid increase of current therein and in the reverse direction to the operating means of the remainin switches.

10. In combination, a plura ity of alternating current feeders, a plurality-of electrical devices, each having an electroresponsive operating means responsive to current in a predetermined direction, a plurality of alternating current to uni-directional current transforming devices, each associated with a corresponding feeder for operation responsively, to predetermined conditions and differential connections extending between the transforming devices and the operating means through which uni-directional current is supplied upon operation of any portion of the transforming devices to a corresponding portion of the operating means in said predetermined direction and to the remainder of said operating means in the opposite direction.

In witness whereof, I have hereunto set my hand this 19th day of June 1928.

JACOB W. MGNAIRY. 

